THE NEW WEST: Earth to Trump

By on April 18, 2017

The past paints a grim picture of what happens in the absence of environmental regulations.

A flag for all citizens, across all borders.

JACKSON HOLE, WY – Earth Day is Saturday—the 47th time it’s been commemorated since the first one was held in 1970.

In many locales, March for Science rallies are happening in support of science and against the Trump administration’s muzzling of scientists, gutting of federal research budgets, and slashing of funding for federal land management agencies, many of them foundational to the lifeblood of the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem.

Last year on Earth Day, the Paris Climate Accord was ratified by the U.S. and nearly 200 other nations, including China, serving as a voluntary framework for reducing human-generated greenhouse gases warming the planet. Under Trump, Scott Pruitt, head of the Environmental Protection Agency, is pushing to have the U.S. withdraw from the agreement and go its own way in the world, denying that anthropogenic climate change is a serious problem.

Every year, we hear grumbling from the usual suspects—including those now identifying as Trumpians—curmudgeons who claim Earth Day as nothing more than a meaningless green pagan cult celebration, the product of hippie flower children leftists aspiring to self-righteously worship at the altar of nature.

Trumpians forget: Earth Day was as much born by mainstream Republican tree huggers as by progressive Democrats. Yet in recent years the spirit of its genesis seems to have been abandoned by most wings of the current GOP who have lost their mooring in the truism that conservation is a conservative ideal.

Let’s quickly recap where America was during the 1960s prior to the advent of Earth Day:

Many of this nation’s rivers were used as garbage disposal systems, carrying toxic waste dumped out the backs of factories, raw untreated sewage and run-off from streets and storm drains filled with paint thinners, poisons and other toxic household products. Some rivers, like the Cuyahoga, caught fire.

In 1969, an oil spill off the coast of Santa Barbara, California, sullied the Pacific Ocean and served as a wake-up call for those who believed that all citizens had to do was listen to fossil fuel companies saying, “Trust us everything will be alright.” The Santa Barbara spill ranks as the third worst behind the Exxon Valdez disaster in 1989 and Deepwater Horizon in 2010.

Smog in urban areas, linked to bad air coming out of auto tailpipes and smokestacks, was causing modern outbreaks of childhood asthma cases and lung diseases.

The country’s public forests were being cut over and liquidated, given away to private timber companies that didn’t want to cash out their own private holdings when the federal government—read uninformed taxpayers—were ever so happy to subsidize their profits by building roads and giving away old growth for pennies on the dollar.

Hardrock and other mines, including those of radioactive uranium and coal, were dug with no reclamation plans, only to be abandoned, leaving taxpayers stuck with Superfund sites and billions of dollars in liabilities; in some cases, giving the public a clean-up burden that will last forever.

Tens of millions of public lands in the West were cleared of bears, wolves, mountain lions, coyotes, and even eagles by poisons, traps and bullets to ensure the landscape posed no threat to cattle and sheep overstocking rangelands. Many of the beneficiaries were not, in fact, mom and pop ranchers but corporate, tax-decrying outfits ever so happy to suckle from federal government subsidies.

Manufacturers of lead paint, lead gasoline and harmful pesticides were making children and others, across generations, sick by being exposed to contamination that diminished brain function and learning skills, harming the lives of poor people at disproportionately higher rates than the wealthy.

Earth Day was supposed to mark a turning point.  The creation of the Environmental Protection Agency was considered a bipartisan statement of hope and conviction that a clean and healthy environment mattered.

Think of this: The Endangered Species Act (the vanguard wildlife protection law in the world), the National Environmental Policy Act (which requires scientific and public review of major management actions), the Clean Air and Clean Water acts, the National Forest Management Act and others came on line during the Nixon years. They were a response to ecological destruction directly linked to a lack of regulation and the failure of the free market to be the conscience of the common good.

Donald Trump will never get Earth Day. On a daily basis he flaunts epic environmental illiteracy. Those in Greater Yellowstone cheerleading his evisceration of longstanding environmental laws don’t get the hypocrisy of their desire to dwell in our region’s public land-rich paradise, which only exists because of Earth Day-era regulations and wise human self-restraint. PJH

Todd Wilkinson has been writing his award-winning New West column for nearly 30 years. It appears weekly in Planet Jackson Hole. He is author of the recent award winning book Grizzlies of Pilgrim Creek, An Intimate Portrait of 399, the Most Famous Grizzly of Greater Yellowstone, featuring photographs by Jackson Hole’s Thomas D. Mangelsen. Special autographed copies are only available at

About Todd Wilkinson

Todd Wilkinson, founder of Mountain Journal (which just published a long piece on climate change in Greater Yellowstone), is also author of Grizzlies of Pilgrim Creek about famous Greater Yellowstone grizzly bear 399 featuring 150 photographs by Tom Mangelsen, available only at

You must be logged in to post a comment Login